I’ve finally done it. I’ve read every published Brandon Sanderson Cosmere novel to date. The journey – and given the length, general number, and content of his novels, I’d say the word journey is an appropriate one – began over 10 years back in undergrad. I have other posts on the matter (https://mweald.com/2024/01/28/on-long-chills-case-dough-brandon-sanderson/), so I won’t go in depth here, but suffice to say he has been an inspiration to me for many years now. His novels, among those of a few other authors, spurred me into writing stories of my own. That being said, just like any author, he has his own strengths and weaknesses. Speaking in terms of his latest Cosmere novel, Wind and Truth, I felt in some ways it typified both where he shines, and where he doesn’t necessarily spend as much focus. No spoilers will follow; they’ve been banished to the deep, to be uncovered at your own leisure, artifacts of another world.
So, let’s do some pro-cons. First off, the sheer scope and audacity of this series. It is astounding. Brandon Sanderson is undoubtedly a master of worldbuilding, of creating coherent magic systems that permeate all facets of the culture. He plots with the obsession and alacrity of one who has truly found in them their method of expression, putting out a sheer volume of work that makes most authors seem ridden with writer’s block. At the same time, this elephantine volume, even if a feature rather than a bug, can wander a bit, and can create a complexity that grows fragile under its own weight. Wind & Truth set out to do an incredible amount, capping the first half of the planned 10 book series: The Stormlight Archive. More than that it handled so many disparate strands weaving throughout the Cosmere. For the most part, I thought it handled this task admirably. I found the final events of the novel to be surprising yet inevitable, giving me what I wanted in a way I did not expect. It gave a sense of resolution to this stage of the Cosmere-wide conflict while marking an intriguing path to the series end. All aspects of a good ending to my mind. Similar remarks for the character arcs. Kaladin, Dalinar, Szeth, Shallan, Renarin, Rlain, Adolin, Jasnah, Navani, and others; they are all represented here, and they show real growth. Brandon Sanderson does love his characters to be at varying levels of broken, and this book is nothing if not a testament to therapy. Nonetheless, this book is a hefty tome. If you feel in danger and this cudgel of a book is sitting nearby, take it in hand and knock that danger into oblivion because this book is heavy enough to be labeled a weapon. Your feelings on this length will vary. Brandon Sanderson writes long books. This is known. And even for him, this is a long book. Personally, there were some parts that I felt could have been removed, but even so, as someone who is prone to verbosity and has been told to winnow down my work and “kill my darlings”, that is, as always, the author’s choice to make. And overall, I quite enjoyed the ride. Journey before destination, even if the journey does wander a bit.
On a different note, let’s talk about the prose. I wouldn’t call sentence by sentence prose Brandon Sanderson’s strong suit insofar as it being of literary genius or clockwork complexity. In some ways his prose can be a weakness; and it is much the same as it has always been in Wind & Truth. But that also misses the point I think. His prose is digestible, readable, consumable. For stories this length and meant to be of wide appeal, that works great, fantastic even. Granted, I do think he relies on telling, rather than the preferable showing, a bit too often, in particular telling us that a character is happy or sad or angry as opposed to showing an emotional act or speech or evocative image. Same as with the length, your feelings on this telling of emotional states will vary. It’s not my favorite. But even so, at the end of the day, I blitzed through this book in the way only a Sanderlanche can enact. It was a fun ride. I give it the book’s hefty weight in lbs of a hearty recommend.
All the best,
M. Weald


